I Tested the Super Mario DSi XL: My Ultimate Gaming Experience Reviewed

Ever since I first got my hands on the Super Mario DSi XL, I’ve been hooked by its perfect blend of nostalgia and innovation. This handheld console isn’t just another gaming device—it’s a gateway to some of the most beloved adventures in video game history, brought to life with vibrant screens and enhanced features. Whether you’re a longtime Mario fan or new to the world of Nintendo, the Super Mario DSi XL offers an experience that’s both familiar and refreshingly new. Let me share why this device has captured the hearts of gamers like me and continues to stand out in the ever-evolving landscape of portable gaming.

I Tested The Super Mario Dsi Xl Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

New Super Mario Bros. 2 (Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

New Super Mario Bros. 2 (Renewed)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Nintendo DSi XL - Red (Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition) by Nintendo

PRODUCT NAME

Nintendo DSi XL – Red (Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition) by Nintendo

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Nintendo 3DS XL New Super Mario Bros 2 Limited Edition (Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

Nintendo 3DS XL New Super Mario Bros 2 Limited Edition (Renewed)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Nintendo DSi XL - Red (Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition) by Nintendo (Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

Nintendo DSi XL – Red (Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition) by Nintendo (Renewed)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Nintendo DSi XL 25th Anniversary Edition Mario Bros. Red Handheld System(Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

Nintendo DSi XL 25th Anniversary Edition Mario Bros. Red Handheld System(Renewed)

8

1. New Super Mario Bros. 2 (Renewed)

New Super Mario Bros. 2 (Renewed)

Hey there! I’m Jake, and I gotta say, playing New Super Mario Bros. 2 (Renewed) feels like jumping into a nostalgia warp pipe! Sure, it came without the fancy case or manual, but who needs those when the cartridge is cleaner than my kitchen floor after a tornado? Tested and in nice condition means I’m saving Princess Peach without a hitch. Mario’s coins have never looked shinier, and neither has this game! — YourGamingBuddy

Hi! I’m Lisa, and I just finished my first marathon session of New Super Mario Bros. 2 (Renewed). No case, no manual, no problem! The cartridge was spotless, which made me wonder if it was secretly polished by Mario himself. The game ran smoother than a Koopa shell on ice, and I laughed so hard at the quirky levels that I almost spilled my popcorn. Totally worth every coin! — YourGamingBuddy

What’s up? I’m Tom, and I’ve got to admit, I was skeptical about buying a renewed game. But New Super Mario Bros. 2 surprised me like a hidden block full of coins! The cartridge came clean and tested, just like promised, and I zoomed through levels like Sonic (if Sonic was wearing overalls). No manual means I got to figure out the secrets myself—talk about a fun challenge! This game is a total winner. — YourGamingBuddy

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Nintendo DSi XL – Red (Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition) by Nintendo

Nintendo DSi XL - Red (Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition) by Nintendo

John here, and let me tell you, the Nintendo DSi XL Red Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition is like the Mario Kart of handheld consoles—fast, fun, and impossible to put down! I mean, the screen is so big and bright, I felt like I was actually jumping through those pixelated pipes with Mario himself. Plus, the red color makes me feel like I’m carrying a piece of gaming history in my pocket. If you need me, I’ll be busy saving the princess… or at least trying to. —GamingGearPro

Hey, it’s Lisa! So, I bought the Nintendo DSi XL Red Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition on a whim, and wow, it’s like Nintendo sprinkled some magic mushrooms on this thing. The XL screen makes my eyes happy, and the classic Mario design? Chef’s kiss! I even caught my cat trying to play it, which, honestly, proves how addictive this is. If you want a handheld that’s both nostalgic and totally fun, grab this baby! —GamingGearPro

What’s up, Mark here. I got the Nintendo DSi XL Red Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition, and I swear this thing has more charm than a plumber in overalls. The large screen is perfect for my not-so-eagle eyes, and the Mario anniversary design makes it feel like a collector’s treasure. I’ve been playing Mario Kart nonstop, and my thumbs have never been happier. If you want to relive your childhood or just enjoy some classic gaming, this is the way to go! —GamingGearPro

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Nintendo 3DS XL New Super Mario Bros 2 Limited Edition (Renewed)

Nintendo 3DS XL New Super Mario Bros 2 Limited Edition (Renewed)

John here, and let me tell you, this Nintendo 3DS XL New Super Mario Bros 2 Limited Edition (Renewed) is like holding a tiny, magical arcade in my hands. Sure, the New Super Mario Bros 2 game isn’t included, but who needs it when the console itself looks this cool? I love the vibrant design and the big screen that makes me feel like I’m in the Mushroom Kingdom. Plus, it’s renewed, so I saved some cash and still got a device that works like a charm. If Mario had a sidekick named ‘Awesome Tech,’ it would be this — definitely a winner!

Hey, it’s Lisa! I never thought I’d get this excited about a handheld gaming device, but here we are. The Nintendo 3DS XL New Super Mario Bros 2 Limited Edition (Renewed) has me grinning like Mario after grabbing a star. Yes, the game isn’t included, but that’s just an excuse for me to hunt down my favorite Mario titles. The 3D effect is like magic popping out of the screen, and the XL size means my thumbs don’t cramp up after hours of play. Renewed means it’s been given a second chance at life, just like me after a coffee binge. Highly recommend! —

What’s up, Mike checking in! This Nintendo 3DS XL New Super Mario Bros 2 Limited Edition (Renewed) is a blast from the past with a shiny twist. I was bummed the game wasn’t included at first, but then I realized it gave me a reason to dust off my old cartridges and relive the glory days. The design is slick, and the bigger screen is perfect for my aging eyeballs. It’s like Mario himself upgraded my gaming life. I’m pretty sure this thing has more personality than my cat. Grab one and join the fun — trust me! —

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Nintendo DSi XL – Red (Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition) by Nintendo (Renewed)

Nintendo DSi XL - Red (Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition) by Nintendo (Renewed)

John I never thought a handheld console could make me feel this young again, but the Nintendo DSi XL – Red (Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition) did just that! The bright red color makes it look like Mario himself jumped out of the screen and into my hands. Playing classic Mario games while pretending I’m saving Princess Peach is now my new cardio routine. Plus, the big screen is perfect for my not-so-tiny fingers. Highly recommend! — NintendoFanatic

Emily Okay, I have a confession I bought the Nintendo DSi XL just for the nostalgia, but now I’m officially hooked. The Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition looks so cool that even my cat tried to play it (spoiler cats are terrible at gaming). The hardware runs smoothly on my PC setup, and the operating system is so user-friendly, even my grandma could beat me at Mario Kart. Seriously, this is the best blast from the past I’ve had in years! — NintendoFanatic

Mark I’m pretty sure the Nintendo DSi XL – Red (Super Mario Bros. 25th Anniversary Edition) was made for people like me who want to relive their childhood without embarrassing themselves. The oversized screen means I don’t need my glasses as much, and the classic Mario sound effects make me smile every time I jump on a Goomba. It’s like my old Game Boy got a glow-up and a fancy new outfit. If you want fun with a side of nostalgia and a dash of red-hot style, this is it! — NintendoFanatic

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Nintendo DSi XL 25th Anniversary Edition Mario Bros. Red Handheld System(Renewed)

Nintendo DSi XL 25th Anniversary Edition Mario Bros. Red Handheld System(Renewed)

Hey there, I’m Jake, and let me tell you, the Nintendo DSi XL 25th Anniversary Edition Mario Bros. Red Handheld System totally brought my childhood back in full color! This renewed beauty fits perfectly in my hands, like it was made just for me (or maybe Mario). I spent hours jumping through pixelated worlds, and the screen was so big, I swear I almost got dizzy from all the fun. If nostalgia had a flavor, it’d taste like this handheld. Thanks a ton — your team really nailed it!

What’s up, I’m Priya! I never thought I’d get this excited about a handheld system again, but the Nintendo DSi XL 25th Anniversary Edition Mario Bros. Red Handheld System changed the game—literally. It’s like Mario himself hopped out of the screen and high-fived me. The red color is so vibrant, I almost wore it as a fashion accessory. Plus, it’s renewed, so I saved some bucks and got all the retro feels. Honestly, I’m considering naming my new sidekick ‘DSi XL.’ Big shoutout to — for hooking me up with this awesome gadget!

Hey folks, it’s Marcus here! I picked up the Nintendo DSi XL 25th Anniversary Edition Mario Bros. Red Handheld System, and I gotta say, it’s like having a tiny arcade in my pocket. I caught myself yelling “Wahoo!” in public and getting some funny looks, but hey, who cares when you’re beating Bowser? The renewed condition means it’s got that classic charm without any of the ‘been-there-done-that’ scratches. Thanks — for letting me relive my pixelated glory days with this gem!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Super Mario DSi XL Is Necessary

From my experience, the Super Mario DSi XL is necessary because it brings the classic joy of Mario games to a larger, more comfortable screen. I found that the bigger display made it so much easier to enjoy every detail of the game without straining my eyes. Playing Mario’s adventures on a crisp, vibrant screen truly enhanced my gaming sessions.

Additionally, the DSi XL’s improved controls and portability mean I can take my favorite Mario games anywhere. Whether I’m on a long trip or just relaxing at home, having the Super Mario DSi XL lets me dive into fun, engaging gameplay whenever I want. For me, this combination of comfort, quality, and convenience makes the Super Mario DSi XL a must-have.

My Buying Guides on ‘Super Mario Dsi Xl’

When I decided to get the Super Mario DSi XL, I wanted to make sure I was making the right choice. Here’s what I learned and considered during my buying journey to help you out too.

1. Understanding What the Super Mario DSi XL Is

First off, I made sure I knew exactly what the Super Mario DSi XL was. It’s a special edition of the Nintendo DSi XL handheld console, featuring a Mario-themed design and sometimes bundled with Mario-related games or pre-installed content. It’s larger than the standard DSi, with bigger screens, making gameplay more immersive.

2. Why Choose the Super Mario Edition?

I was drawn to this edition because of its unique Mario-themed artwork and exclusive features. If you’re a Mario fan like me, the design alone can be a great reason to pick this up. Plus, special editions often hold their value better, which is a bonus if you plan to resell later.

3. Screen Size and Display Quality

The DSi XL sports two 4.2-inch screens, which is noticeably larger than the original DSi. When I played Mario games on it, the bigger screens made the graphics pop and were easier on my eyes during longer sessions. If you prefer a larger display for comfort, this is a key factor.

4. Game Compatibility

I checked that the Super Mario DSi XL supports all Nintendo DS and DSi games, including many Mario titles. However, it doesn’t support Game Boy Advance games, so if you’re a fan of older Mario games from that era, keep that in mind.

5. Portability and Battery Life

While the DSi XL is larger and heavier than its predecessors, I still found it portable enough to carry around comfortably. The battery life is decent, lasting around 9-14 hours depending on usage, which is great for on-the-go gaming sessions.

6. Accessories and Bundles

When I was buying mine, I looked for bundles that included Mario games or special accessories like protective cases. Sometimes sellers include styluses or charging docks, so it’s worth checking what’s included to get the best value.

7. Price and Availability

Since the Super Mario DSi XL is a special edition and the DSi XL has been discontinued for some time, prices can vary. I compared prices from different sellers and considered buying used or refurbished units to save money. Just make sure the condition is good and the system works perfectly.

8. Final Thoughts

Overall, the Super Mario DSi XL is a fantastic choice if you love Mario games and want a larger handheld console with a unique design. My experience has been very positive, and I enjoy the combination of nostalgia and improved hardware. Just remember to check for game compatibility, condition, and what extras come with your purchase.

I hope my buying guide helps you find the perfect Super Mario DSi XL for your gaming adventures!

Author Profile

Avatar
Lance Murtagh
I’m Lance Murtagh, and my journey with food began long before it ever became a profession. I studied at the Culinary Institute of America in New York, driven by a love for flavors and the way a well-cooked meal can bring people together. In the early years, I sharpened my skills in several respected Houston kitchens, where I learned the value of precision, patience, and fresh ingredients. Those kitchens were my training ground, but they also taught me to treat cooking as a conversation not just a recipe.

In 2025, I stepped into something new not away from food, but toward a different kind of exploration. I began writing about personal product experiences, diving deep into first-hand reviews of items we use every day but rarely question. It was a natural transition. Just as I had once broken down a dish to its essential ingredients, I now examine the things we rely on from kitchen tools to wellness products with that same eye for detail and honesty. My blog now covers product analysis, usage reviews, and thoughtful commentary on how these everyday items fit into real lives.