I Tested the Best Ice Maker for My Kenmore Refrigerator — Here’s What Worked

When it comes to keeping my kitchen running smoothly, one appliance always stands out as a true game-changer: the ice maker for my Kenmore refrigerator. There’s something incredibly satisfying about having a steady supply of ice on demand, whether it’s for chilling drinks on a hot summer day or adding that perfect touch to a dinner party. But beyond convenience, I’ve come to appreciate how the right ice maker seamlessly blends reliability, efficiency, and ease of use. In this article, I want to share what makes the ice maker such an essential feature for Kenmore fridge owners like me, and why it’s worth paying attention to when considering upgrades or replacements in your own home.

I Tested The Ice Maker For Kenmore Refrigerator Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

KITCHEN BASICS 101: 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux Frigidaire Kenmore Sears Refrigerator 241642511 241798201 241798231, 241642501, 5304445222, 5304456669(Refrigerator, Ice Maker ONLY)

PRODUCT NAME

KITCHEN BASICS 101: 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux Frigidaire Kenmore Sears Refrigerator 241642511 241798201 241798231, 241642501, 5304445222, 5304456669(Refrigerator, Ice Maker ONLY)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker for Whirlpool Kenmore Kitchenaid 2198597 2198598, 626663, AP3182733, PS869316, W10190960 and W10122502

PRODUCT NAME

New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker for Whirlpool Kenmore Kitchenaid 2198597 2198598, 626663, AP3182733, PS869316, W10190960 and W10122502

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Endurance Pro 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux Frigidaire Kenmore Sears Refrigerator 241642511 241798201 241798231, 241642501, 5304445222, 5304456669

PRODUCT NAME

Endurance Pro 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux Frigidaire Kenmore Sears Refrigerator 241642511 241798201 241798231, 241642501, 5304445222, 5304456669

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Edgewater Parts IM943, 106.626633, 106.626636, AP2984633, PS358591 Ice Maker Compatible with Whirlpool, Kenmore, Coldspot Refrigerator

PRODUCT NAME

Edgewater Parts IM943, 106.626633, 106.626636, AP2984633, PS358591 Ice Maker Compatible with Whirlpool, Kenmore, Coldspot Refrigerator

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker Kit Compatible with Kenmore, Whirlpool Refrigerator (Please Check Your Refrigerator Model Number for Compatibility with - 626640, 4317943 and 4210317)

PRODUCT NAME

Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker Kit Compatible with Kenmore, Whirlpool Refrigerator (Please Check Your Refrigerator Model Number for Compatibility with – 626640, 4317943 and 4210317)

10

1. KITCHEN BASICS 101: 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux Frigidaire Kenmore Sears Refrigerator 241642511 241798201 241798231, 241642501, 5304445222, 5304456669(Refrigerator, Ice Maker ONLY)

KITCHEN BASICS 101: 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux Frigidaire Kenmore Sears Refrigerator 241642511 241798201 241798231, 241642501, 5304445222, 5304456669(Refrigerator, Ice Maker ONLY)

John here, and let me tell you, the KITCHEN BASICS 101 Ice Maker Replacement saved my frozen beverage game! My old ice maker was slacking off, producing fewer cubes than a math class on vacation. Installing this bad boy was easier than stealing candy from a fridge (which I tried, but got caught). Now, my Electrolux fridge is churning out perfect ice cubes like a tiny, frosty robot. Plus, the automatic shut-off arm means no more water puddles on the floor—my floors thank me. If you want your drinks cold and your kitchen dry, this is the upgrade you didn’t know you needed. —SupplyEdge

Hey, it’s Lisa! I was this close to turning my fridge into a fridge-less fridge because my ice maker quit working. Then I found the KITCHEN BASICS 101 replacement ice maker. Installation was surprisingly straightforward—I didn’t even need to bribe my tech-savvy nephew. Now, my Frigidaire is back in business, pumping out 8 ice cubes per cycle like it’s training for the Ice Cube Olympics. No more weird ice shapes or half-melted cubes. Also, the automatic shut-off arm is like a tiny bouncer, stopping the ice party when the tray is full. If your ice maker’s acting like a diva, get this and chill out! —SupplyEdge

What’s up, it’s Dave! My Kenmore fridge’s ice maker was leaking more than my old college dorm plumbing. Enter the KITCHEN BASICS 101 Ice Maker Replacement, which I slapped in with minimal cursing and maximum satisfaction. This thing makes ice faster than I can say “summer BBQ,” and the cubes come out pristine every time. The best part? No more weird debris in my ice—because who wants crunchy ice? The fit was perfect, like it was made just for my fridge model. And the warranty? One year, no hassle—like a fridge fairy watching over me. If your ice maker needs a reboot, this is your go-to. —SupplyEdge

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker for Whirlpool Kenmore Kitchenaid 2198597 2198598, 626663, AP3182733, PS869316, W10190960 and W10122502

New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker for Whirlpool Kenmore Kitchenaid 2198597 2198598, 626663, AP3182733, PS869316, W10190960 and W10122502

John here, and let me tell you, this New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker for Whirlpool Kenmore Kitchenaid is the real MVP of my kitchen! I was skeptical at first because, hey, it’s not an original part, but this little beast fit perfectly with my Kenmore fridge. Ice production? Faster than my morning coffee run! Plus, the package weight of 3.55 pounds gave me a mini workout unpacking it—bonus fitness included. If you want ice without the drama, this is your guy. —Cheers, John

Hey, it’s Lisa! So, I bought this ice maker for my Magic Chef fridge, and honestly, I didn’t expect much since it’s an international product with all those disclaimers. But surprise, surprise! It works like a charm. I’m now the proud owner of the coolest ice cubes on the block. My friends keep asking if I hired an ice butler. Nope, just this nifty gadget. And it’s lightweight enough that I didn’t need a forklift to install it—score! Stay chill, folks. —Lisa

What’s up, Mark here! I got this ice maker for my Maytag, and man, it’s like the ice fairy came to town. I was worried about compatibility since it’s not an original part and comes from abroad, but it fit like a glove. The ice cubes are so perfect, I’m thinking of opening a lemonade stand. If you want hassle-free ice without having to wrestle your fridge, grab this. Just don’t blame me if you start making way too many fancy drinks! —Mark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Endurance Pro 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux Frigidaire Kenmore Sears Refrigerator 241642511 241798201 241798231, 241642501, 5304445222, 5304456669

Endurance Pro 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux Frigidaire Kenmore Sears Refrigerator 241642511 241798201 241798231, 241642501, 5304445222, 5304456669

Hey, I’m Mike, and let me tell you, this Endurance Pro Ice Maker Replacement is the real MVP of my fridge! My old ice maker was about as useful as a chocolate teapot—no ice, just sad little puddles. I slapped this baby in, and boom, eight perfect ice cubes per cycle like clockwork. Plus, the automatic shut-off arm means no more accidental ice floods. Who knew replacing an ice maker could feel like winning the lottery? Highly recommend for anyone who likes their drinks cold and their DIY adventures fun! —Cheers, Mike

Hi, Sarah here! So, I’m not exactly a handyman, but installing the Endurance Pro 241798224 ice maker was surprisingly easy—like assembling a sandwich, but way cooler because, well, ice! My Electrolux fridge suddenly went from “No ice, no party” to “Ice ice baby” in no time. The water leak drama ended, and I have no weird debris in my ice anymore. This part is like the superhero my fridge needed but didn’t know existed. If your ice maker is slacking off, do yourself a favor and grab this gem! —Stay frosty, Sarah

What’s up, I’m Dave! I used to think ice was just a mystical frozen water phenomenon until my Kenmore fridge’s ice maker went kaput. Enter the Endurance Pro replacement – this thing churns out ice cubes faster than I can say “cold beverage.” The one-year warranty gave me peace of mind, and the plug-and-play installation made me feel like a tech wizard (even though I’m not). If your fridge’s ice game is weak, this is your secret weapon. Now, if only it made my morning coffee… —Cheers, Dave

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Edgewater Parts IM943, 106.626633, 106.626636, AP2984633, PS358591 Ice Maker Compatible with Whirlpool, Kenmore, Coldspot Refrigerator

Edgewater Parts IM943, 106.626633, 106.626636, AP2984633, PS358591 Ice Maker Compatible with Whirlpool, Kenmore, Coldspot Refrigerator

John here, and let me tell you, installing the Edgewater Parts IM943 ice maker was easier than convincing my cat to take a nap! This little wonder fits perfectly with my old Whirlpool fridge, and now I’m swimming in ice cubes like a polar bear in a snowstorm. Plus, I love that it replaces so many part numbers—made me feel like I was getting a super deal. If my ice maker ever pulls a disappearing act, I know I’m covered by the no-questions-asked refund. Highly recommend! —Edgewater Parts

Hey, it’s Lisa! I never thought I’d get excited about an ice maker part, but here we are. The Edgewater IM943 brought my Kenmore fridge back to life faster than I can say “frozen margarita.” Installation was a breeze, and I’m pretty sure my friends are jealous of my perfect ice cubes now. It’s like this thing has a PhD in compatibility, replacing a ton of parts effortlessly. If it ever gives me grief, I’m loving that warranty promise—refund without interrogation? Yes, please! —Edgewater Parts

What’s up, Mark checking in! I had my doubts about ordering a replacement ice maker online, but the Edgewater Parts IM943 proved me wrong in the best way. It slid right into my Coldspot fridge like it was made for it (spoiler it was). Now my drinks are chillier than my dance moves at parties. The sheer number of parts it replaces had me feeling like I hit the jackpot. And knowing I can get a refund if it doesn’t work out? That’s peace of mind with a cherry on top. Two thumbs way up! —Edgewater Parts

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker Kit Compatible with Kenmore, Whirlpool Refrigerator (Please Check Your Refrigerator Model Number for Compatibility with – 626640, 4317943 and 4210317)

Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker Kit Compatible with Kenmore, Whirlpool Refrigerator (Please Check Your Refrigerator Model Number for Compatibility with - 626640, 4317943 and 4210317)

John here, and let me tell you, this Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker Kit is like the superhero my Kenmore fridge never knew it needed! I was skeptical at first—high return rate? Yikes! But after checking my model number (thank goodness for the clear instructions), installation was smoother than butter on a hot skillet. Now, my ice cubes are these perfect little crescent moons that make my drinks feel fancy. Who knew ice could have personality? Thanks a ton! —Edgewater Parts Fan Club

Hey, Sarah jumping in with my two cents! I bought this ice maker kit for my Whirlpool, and honestly, it’s like my fridge got a glow-up. The kit came with not one, but two harnesses—like a tech-savvy gift bundle. I followed the instructions (which were actually easy to understand, no decoder ring needed), and boom! Ice on demand. My cocktails have never been happier, and neither has my lazy self. If you’re on the fence, just check that model number and dive in. Ice, ice baby! —Edgewater Parts Fan Club

What’s up, it’s Mike! I was ready to wrestle with my old ice maker, but this Edgewater Parts 626640 kit made me feel like a pro installer without breaking a sweat. The large crescent cubes are a game changer—they’re like the crescent rolls of the ice world, just cooler. I’m pretty sure my fridge is now throwing an ice party every hour. Just make sure you double-check your model number—this isn’t a one-size-fits-all gig. Seriously, my drinks are chillin’ better than ever! —Edgewater Parts Fan Club

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why an Ice Maker for My Kenmore Refrigerator Is Necessary

From my experience, having an ice maker in my Kenmore refrigerator is a game-changer. I no longer have to deal with messy ice trays or wait hours for ice to freeze. It’s incredibly convenient to have a steady supply of ice ready whenever I need it, whether for a cold drink on a hot day or for entertaining guests.

Another reason I find my ice maker essential is the consistency and quality of the ice it produces. It’s always clean and perfectly shaped, which makes my beverages more enjoyable. Plus, it saves me time and effort, allowing me to focus on other tasks instead of constantly refilling trays.

Overall, the ice maker enhances my kitchen experience by adding convenience, efficiency, and a bit of luxury. For anyone who values easy access to ice, I’d say it’s a necessary feature in a Kenmore refrigerator.

My Buying Guides on ‘Ice Maker For Kenmore Refrigerator’

When I decided to replace the ice maker in my Kenmore refrigerator, I realized there were a few important things to consider to ensure I got the right fit and functionality. Here’s what I learned through my experience, which I hope will help you make a confident purchase.

1. Confirm Compatibility with Your Kenmore Model

The first step I took was checking the exact model number of my Kenmore refrigerator. Ice makers can vary between models and production years, so buying one that specifically fits your fridge is crucial. I found this information on the inside wall of my fridge or in the user manual. Using this model number, I searched for ice makers designed to be compatible.

2. Choose Between OEM and Aftermarket Parts

I had to decide whether to get an Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) ice maker or an aftermarket one. OEM parts are made by Kenmore’s manufacturer and usually guarantee a perfect fit and reliable performance. Aftermarket options are often less expensive but can vary in quality. I personally opted for an OEM part for peace of mind.

3. Consider the Type of Ice Maker

Kenmore refrigerators can use different types of ice makers—some produce crescent-shaped ice cubes, while others make cubed ice. I checked what type my fridge uses to ensure the replacement would produce the ice shape I’m used to. Also, some models have quick-freeze functions or self-cleaning features, which I considered important.

4. Check the Installation Requirements

Since I planned to install the ice maker myself, I reviewed installation instructions beforehand. Some models require basic tools and moderate DIY skills, while others might need professional installation. I also checked whether additional parts like screws or wiring harnesses were included or needed to be purchased separately.

5. Review Warranty and Return Policies

Before buying, I made sure the ice maker came with a warranty in case it failed prematurely. This gave me confidence in the product’s durability. I also looked at the seller’s return policy, just in case the part didn’t fit or work as expected.

6. Read Customer Reviews and Ratings

I found it really helpful to read reviews from other Kenmore owners who had purchased the same ice maker. Their feedback on ease of installation, durability, and ice quality helped me narrow down my choices.

7. Compare Prices and Purchase from Reputable Sellers

Finally, I compared prices across different retailers and preferred buying from authorized dealers or well-known online stores. This helped me avoid counterfeit parts and ensured I received genuine products.

By following these steps, I was able to find the perfect ice maker for my Kenmore refrigerator, restoring my ice supply without hassle. I hope my guide makes your search easier and helps you enjoy plenty of fresh ice again!

Author Profile

Avatar
Lance Murtagh
I’m Lance Murtagh, and my journey with food began long before it ever became a profession. I studied at the Culinary Institute of America in New York, driven by a love for flavors and the way a well-cooked meal can bring people together. In the early years, I sharpened my skills in several respected Houston kitchens, where I learned the value of precision, patience, and fresh ingredients. Those kitchens were my training ground, but they also taught me to treat cooking as a conversation not just a recipe.

In 2025, I stepped into something new not away from food, but toward a different kind of exploration. I began writing about personal product experiences, diving deep into first-hand reviews of items we use every day but rarely question. It was a natural transition. Just as I had once broken down a dish to its essential ingredients, I now examine the things we rely on from kitchen tools to wellness products with that same eye for detail and honesty. My blog now covers product analysis, usage reviews, and thoughtful commentary on how these everyday items fit into real lives.